Jim Stone once owned the Pickleville Country Store but sold it and moved to Alaska, where he has been living off the grid for nearly four years. He unexpectedly now has the store back. He shared the story of how he first came to own it
I had been guiding for about 10 years. I had been saving all of my money from tips. I called it my dirty sock money. After I would do a guide trip, I would take the the tip money and stash it in a dirty sock. I thought that was a pretty safe place, that nobody would be looking in a bunch of dirty socks for a stash of money. I had no idea how much money I had.
There used to be two gas pumps in front of the store. I was in my mid twenties and I was up here hunting and I pulled in. I was driving a Toyota Land Cruiser and I filled my tank up and I went inside the store and there was this kind of gruff guy in there, an older gentleman, and I had forgotten my wallet. This guy says, well I am probably going to have to call the cops on you. Then we stared talking and I told him that I was up here fishing all the time and he says, "OK, how about you leave me your shotgun and your driver's license and you run back home and get the money that you owe me." So, I did and I came back and we ended up becoming friends.
About a year later I was in talking with him, and he was the type of guy that loved to fish and hunt, so he was sharing some of his hunting and fishing secrets with me and different things about him and we ended up to be pretty good friends. He said that he and his wife were older and thinking about selling the store.
I told him I would be really interested in buying the store and asked him if he would be willing to carry the loan. He said he would, but there would have to be a pretty substantial down payment. So I thought. about all of the dirty sock money I had stashed from 10 years of guiding. I didn't even know how much money was there. I told him I would see what I could come up with.
I ran back home and I must had had twenty or twenty-five dirty socks and they were just packed full of money. I started counting the money out and had $42,000 in cash. It was unbelievable. So I grabbed that money and came up here (I took it out of the dirty socks, of course) and he didn't have any customers in the store. So, I laid $40,000 in cash in fives, tens, 20s and 50s and 100 dollar bills. So you can imagine what $40,000 in cash would look like sitting on a counter. I said, "I have got $40,000 down. Would that be enough for a down payment to buy your store?"
He said it would be and that they would owner finance the store for me for 9% interest. That was quite a lot. That is how I came about buying this store. It had been built in 1930.
There is a sign on the window that says "Utah Liquor Control Commission 1935". It was a liquor store. The center part of the store was a beer bar and was named El Centro. The downstairs of the store was used for moonshine and illegal gambling. Out back was an actual brothel. There are nine little hotel rooms in what looks like an old shed now, as the people that took over the store didn't keep that part cleaned up.
I made a lot of improvements after I bought the store. I wanted to fix up the little rooms in the back, but couldn't get permission from the city because I didn't have enough parking.
I only had parking for 200 square feet so I turned one of the old brothel buildings into the cute building out back and served raspberry shakes and sandwiches out of it and it became kind of a hub of Bear Lake. Then I had a great big raspberry patches. They are gone now. They grew all of the way along the deck and then I had a trail coming all the way through the center of this little yard. It was full of raspberries and strawberries so people could pick them and I would make them a berry shake with them. I even had red currants and gooseberry currants.
Some of the old signs are still here for subs and shakes. We named the restaurant The Big Pickle and we would serve those great big giant pickles and they were a big hit to a lot of people.
There is an apartment upstairs. That is where I lived and the center floor is actually the store.
That is the story of how I bought the Pickleville Country Store. It was actually a little grocery store and I turned it into a sporting good/grocery store/rental shop and I was renting paddle boards and sea kayaks and bicycles and then I was running the store and also the little shake shop.
Sending you a great big smile from my old store, Pickleville Country Store.